I have never had another kind of potato salad that I liked, probably because most had ‘crunchies,’ which I don’t like. My husband does not like pickles. Growing up, he also believed he did not like potato salad, although his mother assured him there were no pickles in it. He only discovered after we had been married for two years that, not only did he like my potato salad, but his mother had been putting pickle juice in hers all those years! I have brought this potato salad to every pot luck and BBQ I have ever attended and it has never failed that at least one person has asked for the recipe. I tried to find the origins of potato salad and reports vary wildly; however, it appears that my recipe is a cross-breed between German and American versions.
Ingredients:
- 5 Medium Potatoes
- 5 Eggs
- 3/4 C Mayonnaise
- 1 T Mustard
- 1 t Vinegar
- 1 T Milk
- >1/2 t Onion Powder
- 1/4 t Garlic Powder
- 1/2 t Celery Salt
- <1/2 t Dill Weed
- 1/2 t Pepper
- 1/4 t Paprika
Hard boil eggs (slowly bring to a boil, turn down and simmer 15 minutes, remove from heat and let sit 5 minutes, drain and fill pan with cool water, let sit until eggs are cooled). Peel and quarter potatoes. Boil until soft enough to spear with a fork (about 15 minutes). Blend liquids and spices in large bowl. Drain potatoes and add to liquid/spice mixture. Peels eggs. Slice 4 eggs in three directions and add to mixture. Stir well. Even out surface with a spoon. Slice the last egg in only one direction and arrange slices along the top. Shake a small amount of paprika over the top. Can be served still warm (YUM) but keep refrigerated.